Eucatastrophe at the Eschaton

The fifth section of The Doors of the Sea contains Hart’s central concerns with inadequate Christian theodicies (as he considers them), and is the section where he showcases Ivan Karamazov’s rebellion against God. “This is the splendid perversity and genius of Ivan’s (or Dostoyevsky’s) argument, which makes it indeed the argument of a rebel rather …

Judgmental Non-Judgmentalism

In the next chapter, Boyd’s tendency to hydroplane on various evangelical cliches catches up with him. His central argument is that evangelical Christians have the beam in their eye, and hence are in no position to be “moral guardians” for the rest of the country. There’s a lot to that argument, actually, but the problem …

Some Normal People

The first draft of Evangellyfish (the next chapter of which is now posted) didn’t have John Mitchell in it. The entire cast of characters consisted of skunks and scoundrels. The problem with that approach was that there was no opportunity for a reader with reasonable morals to breathe. I say all this because this chapter …