The Very Marchiest of Letters

Sharing Options
Show Outline with Links

Theological Implications of Alien Life Forms

Is it time to consider the theological ramifications of aliens? That’s not a joke. It would cause me tremendous doubt if indisputable evidence comes out about there being other life forms . It seems a rewriting of many if not all bedrock Christians claims would need to be reimagined.

Jimmy

Jimmy, I actually don’t think so. We already know about many alien life forms—cherubim, seraphim, archangels, thrones, dominions, principalities and powers.

Foreign Policy & Israel

Does national Israel (i.e. the government, not the physical descendants of Abraham) have any theological implications, or is it just a nation whose government is geopolitically convenient (as opposed to, say, Afghanistan)?
In other relationships between nations, these United States are clearly the thought leader. Swaziland has basically no impact on US government ideology or direction. Canada is the little brother and everyone knows it. The UK might have once been the thought leader, was a near-peer for a while, and might not be so much anymore. Israel tries to punch above its weight in this area. Shouldn’t we be particularly cautious not to be submissive when nations seek to lead? China does, and we are rightly suspicious. Why should we be less cautious with the state of Israel?

Plain Plainsman

PP, I believe that American foreign policy should be geared to American interests. That does not mean that we don’t care at all about the issues that other nations face, but the central responsibility of our leaders is to protect and guard the United States. Not only are we not the world’s policeman, we are also not the world’s babysitter. As someone who is not a Zionist, I believe that the rights and responsibilities of Israel should be on the same footing as all the other nations. And with that said, it is in America’s best interest to be in a good relationship with Israel, but without putting Israel’s interests ahead of our own.

One-Man Bible Translations?

Do you read any translations of the Bible done by individuals? Thoughts as to advantages vs. disadvantages compared to committee-based translations?
Also, what do you think about the translation of the divine name (YHWH)? Do you see any major trends in translation on the horizon? Any trends that need to be retired?
Thanks!

Caleb

Caleb, my general Bible reading practice is to read my base translation (KJV) every other time. The in-between times I vary the translations I read, and have often read translations by just one person—Knox, Moffat, Philips, Lattimore, and so on. It helps to keep the pot stirred. I don’t think it is necessary to be fastidious about the name YHWH because the New Testament doesn’t. For example, the Hebrew YHWH is rendered in the New Testament as kurios, lord (Joel 2:32; Rom. 10:13), and is not transliterated. And my main concern about translation is that the church makes her way back to the Byzantine text type.

Product Idea

I had a tidbit of an idea related to product/resource creation . . . I noticed the Femina daily quote calendar on the Canon website. It would be neat to have different versions of those related to topic. Like Christian Leadership, Parenting, Ancient Wisdom, etc. Getting to supply the best quotes of old about all of those topics definitely interests me and is something I would consider purchasing. Just food for thought. I have found your insights related to parenting and family extremely useful as we recently adopted a baby boy. Our first child. Thanks for all you do,

Chris

Chris, interesting idea. Thanks. I passed it on to Canon.

Saving and Investing

What are your thoughts on investing in the stock market? Should we as Christians do it? Do you do it? If Christians ought NOT do it, how best can we be wise with our money to take financial care of ourselves in our latter years and leave a (monetary) inheritance to our children? And how does the parable of the talents come into play here, if at all?
I understand the parable of the talents is not referring specifically to finances, necessarily but does it extend into it and how? Many Christians we speak to use this parable to justify using the stock market (and pretty much forget the original intent). My husband is in his late 40’s and does not have any sizable retirement set aside for the future while his siblings are all sitting on sizable ’empty-nest eggs’. We are not sure how to go about preparing for our financial future in a God-honoring way but want to do right. How would you council us?

Rebecca

Rebecca, I think that saving against the future is a responsible thing to do, and investing in the stock market is certainly lawful. The two things to watch out for there would be unethical investments, on the one hand, and foolhardy and risky investing on the other. But there are other ways to do it as well, e.g. paying down your mortgage, or simple discipline with a savings account.

Sabbath Dinners

You mentioned Sabbath dinners in your video on in-laws. My wife and I were each raised in nominally Christian homes but aspire to build a family with rhythms like your Sabbath dinner. Can you explain those dinners to someone with zero experience with them growing up, maybe the general details and how you went about building it into a rhythm?

AH

AH, we have been celebrating sabbath dinners for going on thirty years now, so there have been many permutations based on number and age of grandkids and so on. But the main ingredients are two—first, a regular and repeated gathering of family on a weekly basis, and secondly, what might be called a ritual beginning to the dinner, beyond the mere saying of grace. We begin with a toast: “This is the day that the Lord has made,” and everyone responds, “We will rejoice and be glad in it.” Then I say grace, thanking the Lord for the arrival of yet another sabbath. Then I ask all the kids, “What is the blessing for my wife?” and they respond by reciting Proverbs 9:1. Then, “What is the blessing for the children?” and the answer is a recitation of Psalm 144: 12. Then I ask a series of questions to all the kids: “Do you love God? Yes! Are you baptized? Yes! Is Jesus in your heart? Yes! Will you take the Lord’s Supper tomorrow? Yes!” These are all for the younger kids. Then I ask particular catechism questions to various kids by name. “Who made you?” “What day is it?” and so on. Then I ask them all, “What is the point of the whole Bible?” and they answer “Kill the dragon, get the girl!” Then we sing, usually Psalm 134, but sometimes the Doxology. Then we thank the hosts, and get instructions on the buffet line. And that’s it.

Homosexual Temptation

I hope you are doing well. I am curious, what are your thoughts regarding this claim?
“Homosexual people can be Christians if and only if their attraction to the same gender stays private, they don’t ‘act on’ those desires, and/or if they remain celibate for the rest of their lives.”
I believe the claim mentioned above belongs to what I think may be called “Side-B Christianity.” I believe such people can be saved, and through repentance and faith, counseling, and prayer, can find themselves either struggling less with the sin or no longer struggling with it. Such people can still marry someone of the opposite gender in the Lord. They don’t have to hold that sin as their permanent identity, just as a kleptomaniac doesn’t have to find their identity in their kleptomania. I would think keeping people in a state of believing their sin is still their identity violates 2 Corinthians 5:17. I’ve become rather convinced that the attraction itself is sinful, but I would like to know your thoughts.
Thank you!

ON

ON, yes, I agree with you. It is not enough to keep the whole thing in the closet. Disordered affections are themselves sinful, which is why justification is necessary. But, depending on how far the thought processes of a particular temptation developed, it is not necessarily required to confess that vulnerability as a specific sin. A man does not need to confess lusting after another man if he in fact didn’t lust after another man. But he should recognize that the bent nature of his desires, and the direction they would go if he let them, is a sinful condition that is in need of the imputed righteousness of Christ.

Fasting

I have 2 questions about the spiritual discipline of fasting.
I had never given it much thought as it was not taught nor encouraged specifically at my Church. In part I can understand this as Jesus instructed us to perform it privately. But I also feel like it might just be a discipline that has fallen by the wayside. Also I think of Esther asking the Jews to fast and pray for her as giving her encouragement.
So my first question: is there a place for telling others that you are prayerfully fasting for them during a hard time or telling others that you have fasted and found it beneficial?
Secondly, I found fasting emphasized in a spiritual discipline book that I was reading during a season of attempting a one meal a day diet for the purposes of reaching a healthy weight. Now I have trouble not thinking about the weight loss benefits when choosing to do a spiritual fast. This seems to take away from part of my purpose of prayerfully fasting. How can I moderate this or am I being a weaker brother with an overactive conscience?
Thank you for you continued serrated wisdom!
P.S. I am loving your dad’s books that have been added to Canon plus!

Stephen

Stephen, thanks for your kind comments. I think that as a general rule, private fasting ought not to be shared with anyone. When a community is fasting together, there is no particular pride of place that would come from other people knowing about it, so fewer worries there. And it does sound as though you might be overthinking it when it comes side blessings such as weight loss. Not all diets are fasting, but all fastings are diets. So just incorporate a caution for yourself in your prayers, and keep on.

Deleted Links?

For several weeks your Friday blog has had some links deleted. I assume it is done by the gatekeepers who object to something you have printed in the blog. I also assume I am not the only subscriber who is experiencing this difficulty. Are you aware that this is happening and do you know why?

Howard

Howard, we have not had any recent evidence of hostiles deleting links. A more likely explanation might be the incompetence of the proprietor here.

Quite a Mess

Thanks for your ministry. Our church has gotten itself in quite a mess. The head pastor was arrested for drunk driving in late December and it was found out the he lied to the church about the circumstances surrounding the event, how much he drank, etc. The elders dismissed him because it was the third event that he’d had with public drunkenness in the past several years. (There were more events and a clear pattern of too much drinking but those three involved other church members/public events.) The pastor then showed up with the cops to kick the elders out of the building because “his attorney said their names weren’t on the church founding documents” but then he decided to leave for good and start another church.
Our good friends are friends with the pastor and spent several weeks calling members of our joint small group lobbying them to leave the church and go to the new church that the old pastor was starting. The husband in particular has spent a lot of time trying to “explain the other side and how the elders were wrong and should have restored the pastor to the head pastor role” but it’s really meant that he’s been divisive, causing multiple families to leave the church. Additionally, since the pastor’s firing two months ago, they have not reached out to us, despite our previous usual routine being to hang out once a week.
I respect your opinion and would be curious on your take for what is our responsibility to the church regarding not socializing with a (former) church brother that’s being divisive versus maintaining our friendship with them. What advice would you have?

Jeff

Jeff, I would start by making sure that you are proceeding on the basis of undisputed facts, as it sounds like you are. In other words, the defense of the pastor is not that he has a twin brother with a drinking problem. If your former friend has taken up an unrighteous cause, and is pursuing it in an unrighteous manner, then there is no way to get together as old friends without dealing with the elephant in the room. You should make at least one attempt to do so, and if that is unsuccessful, you should just walk away.

Emotional Infidelity

I am a 23 year-old newlywed (we married in May of last year), and both my wife and I have had our struggles with pornography prior to marriage. We sought counseling from our pastors and are seeing wonderful fruit of repentance and obedience in these areas.
One area, however, where I have continued to struggle is in the realm of what I call “emotional cheating.” I work in a nursing home with all-female coworkers, and sometimes I will find myself joking with them in the hopes of making them laugh (it feels good to make a pretty girl laugh), or I will catch myself wanting to protect/overly help them. At church events as well, I will sometimes notice that I too-long admire the smile of another woman in the congregation, or I catch my imagination begin to play alternate histories of if we had dated rather than me and my wife.
Obviously, I understand that lust is lust, and playing out and/or desiring sexual interactions with other women is that sin; but this sin feels related and yet distinct. How can I as a newly wed battle against this similar sinful temptation, and avoid emotional infidelity?
Sincerely,

JS

JS, yes, it is distinct, and yes, it is related. My advice to you is to categorize this temptation as a much more serious issue than the porn was (which was also serious). The reason is that this kind of infatuation with actual people is the kind of thing that can creep slowly into actual adultery. Every time you catch yourself doing any of these things, treat it like a venomous snake, and mortify it.

Parenting Adults

Do you know of any books (or have you ever written any articles, etc.) regarding the topic of parenting adult children? Especially for those who now have regrets/guilt about the way they approached things, children who failed to launch, are spendthrifts, not attending church, not great parents, and so on and so forth.
Thanks.

Tim

Tim, sorry, I don’t have a great book recommendation. Maybe others out there do? But the one thing that you might start with is a small piece my father wrote. Here is a link: How to Lead Your Wayward Children Back to the Lord.

How Much to Confess?

I was recently reading Richard Baxter and came across some interesting words on confession of sin. It was in a section titled “Cases and Directions About Confessing Sins and Injuries to Others”
Quote:
[Question II. What causes will excuse us from confessing wrongs to others?
Answer. 1. When full recompense may be made without it and no forgiveness of the wrong is necessary from the injured, nor any of the aforesaid causes require it. 2. When the wrong is secret and not known to the injured party, and the confessing of it would but trouble his mind, and do more harm than good . . . 7. In general, it is no duty to confess our sin to him that we have wronged, when, all things considered, it is like in the judgement of the truly wise, to do more hurt than good for it is appointed as a means to good, and not to do evil.]
What is your position on this?.

John

John, I agree with Baxter completely. Say you have had a spiteful attitude toward a friend for six months, and that friend is serenely unaware of it. When you get that right with God, you should not go to your friend and say, “sorry for hating you all this time.” You are just making a mess, not cleaning one up. But if that friend had come to you several times during those months to ask if anything was wrong, and you lied to them, confessing to them is a necessity. They knew something was wrong, and you need to put it right.

Some Practical Advice

Can I get some practical advice? My wife and I were just talking about how circumstances affect us. For example, a super high stress job or five sleepless nights in a row.
We know there is no excuse for sin. But we also know, if we get two hours of sleep for several nights in a row, somebody is gonna snap at the kids.
We repent and hope we get sanctified enough to where this doesn’t happen.
How do we handle this stuff? We feel like goobers.

Thomas

Thomas, this reminds me of a joke. “Doctor, it hurts when I do this.” Patient moves his arm in an odd way. Doctor says, “Well, don’t do that.” What I would encourage you to do is to work on the things that set you up. Manage the high stress job better. Make sure to budget for enough sleep. And of course, if you stumble, confess it to God and to the kids,

Faith Commitments and Schools

What expectations does Logos school have in terms of the faith commitments of the families involved at the school? Do you allow families who aren’t part of a local church or who aren’t professing believers to send their kids there? Are the kids required to be believers by a certain age to continue attending?

Nick

Nick, we used to accept kids from non-Christian families (in limited numbers), provided they understood that we were going to be teaching the truths of the Christian faith. That worked well, but we discontinued it because of the legal climate, and the prospect of a legal action from the alphabet people. Now students need to have at least one believing parent.

Thanks

Thank you for taking the time to write and make videos. I appreciate your wisdom and honesty in tackling issues many people don’t want to acknowledge. I am praying God will give many others, including myself, the strength and courage to be as bold as you have been in sharing His truth. You are one of my favorite pastors.

Suzanne

Suzanne, thank you for paying attention. That’s the hard part.
After long delayed plans, I am finally making it out west to visit an elderly relative who extended the invite through most of last year. However, after purchasing airline tickets, I realized a conundrum into which I was placing myself with the selected dates over the weekend. Most of that side of the family attend very liberal Protestant congregations, and my host’s home church in the hippie mountain town is a United Church of Christ, replete with a rainbow-stoled priestess and a website stuffed to the gills with rather unorthodox affirmations—or rather with unabashed affirmations of every element of modern secularism.
As a seminary grad and as her guest, I am a bit torn as what would be right or best to do here. Do I duck my head and take the opportunity to quietly study enemy territory that Sunday morning, hoping and praying for an opportunity after the services to discuss with her the gospel or the lack thereof (a la J Gresham Machen)? Or should I make prior arrangements to attend elsewhere out of a stand on Christian convictions about the lack of fellowship with a denomination and local body that has lurched so far into apostasy? My initial research shows the only other in-town options to be a Mormon church and a Catholic mission. I have a classmate and former roommate who also resides in the state and pastors a congregation, but he would be over a 90-min drive away.
Not sure if you have counseled congregants of your own who have faced such a conundrum, but I would appreciate any advice or insights you might have to share regarding how to navigate with truth, love, and tact in this scenario. I am certainly praying for such things in this forthcoming trip, and that I might be appropriately forthright and courageous in word or deed but not foolhardy or rash (as I may have been after the last time I sat through a church service with a lady preacher and got more than a little hot under my collar).

Call Me Ishmael

CMI, a lot depends on your relationship to family there. If they would be understanding if you attended elsewhere, that seems simplest. But if they wouldn’t mind if you attended as an observer (not a worshiper), you might learn a lot, and be in a better position to talk with you family about all of it. The one thing you should not do is attend, and try to worship together with them.

Christian Halls

Have you ever heard of Christian Halls? And if so, what are your thoughts?
It’s supposedly a network (classically oriented) to help Christian communities offer their kids higher education, but still Christ-centered.
I was just informed that the Administrator of the school that I help oversee as an Elder of the sponsoring church had a meeting with some significant figures in our community about launching one of these Halls, and thought I would ask if you were privy of this structure at all. Thanks for your time!

Ben

Ben, I have heard of them, but don’t really know a lot about them. But from what I see, I do believe that all efforts like this should be encouraged and cheered on.

Recovering Baptist . . .

Your book To a Thousand Generations really has messed me up . . . I’ve been a baptist all my life and now I find myself, a member in good standing, at a baptist church that I don’t want to leave, but with the conviction that I should have all my young children baptized. I know my pastors will never baptize them until they are able to make a profession of faith.
What are my options? I don’t want to create division in the body. And I also truly respect my pastor’s authority. Any counsel you can give from a distance? Have you ever heard of a Baptist church “outsourcing” baptisms for people like me who come to different convictions after many years of fellowship?

J

J, yes, there are Baptist churches that would “outsource,” but they are rare. And those that would outsource are likely in some sort of transition themselves. I would meet with your pastor and give me a fair opportunity to talk you off the ledge. Don’t present him with a fait accompli, in other words. If he fails to get you off the ledge, assure him that you are going to be the very opposite of divisive, and I would begin praying about finding a new church home. If you find one, and join it, make sure to come back regularly to visit your friends at this church.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Douglas
David Douglas
8 hours ago

Doug Wilson,

Re: your use of “The Alphabet People”
This term is now the equivalent of Dead-Naming. They have been “The Alpha-Numeric People” for several years now.

Mind you, I’m not judging. Sooo not judging…

Andrew Lohr
Andrew Lohr
7 hours ago

Caleb–two individual translations I value are Jay Greens’s “King James II” Bible, if you can find one–more verve than the New King James committee product, tho dozens of typos. And Young’s Literal: may be too hard for some people (and could be made even more literal), but gives the text in a bit raw-er form; a different kind of accuracy than modern paraphrases offer, tho each has its place. How it was Written is part of what is Written; if the Holy Ghost inspired a present tense, who are we to lay down the law that English requires a future… Read more »

Jake
7 hours ago

Jimmy, I heard another pastor answer the aliens question with Are they fallen or unfallen? Since all of creation fell with Adam, any space aliens would have to be fallen.

Rob
Rob
3 hours ago
Reply to  Jake

Christ only died once and he did so here on earth, not an alien planet. We might understand this to mean that no other fallen, redeemable creatures are in the universe. We should just stop speculating on such non-sense.

Jake
6 hours ago

J, ho young are your children? Encourage them to make confessions and then they can be bapti3ed. Unless they are under four, you should not have a problem here.