Surface Appearances

So let me begin my comments about Son of God, the Movie by saying that there are tons of evangelicals who are excited about this movie because of the evangelistic opportunities it represents. Their motives are pure and happy, and I wish everybody well. I hope that lots of people who are given pre-bought theater tickets pray the prayer.

Let me also begin these comments by saying that I will do my level best to keep the Second Commandment out of this. This not because the Second Commandment is irrelevant — indeed, that commandment lurks in the background of all Jesus movies, as the great unspoken explanation for why these movies are so consistently lame. It might help you follow these comments if you know that my general outlook on these things is akin to the views of the Scots Covenanters, and my idea of an ecclesiastical relic is a Claymoor hanging in the narthex. So you will have to grant me some leeway on the subject.

That said, and judging by the trailer — which is what they want us to judge by, right? — we have yet another Jesus who perpetuates our perennial and mule-headed idea that holiness consists of one part anemia, one part effeminacy, two parts stoner-mystique, and one part slight constipation, this time with a British accent. But I don’t want a Russell Brand Jesus.

Russell Brand Jesus

The Lord’s first command was “follow me,” and so why do we always get these guys that you wouldn’t want to follow for ninety seconds on an escalator?

When King of Kings first came out several generations ago, one insightful lady of the English aristocracy wrote that if Jesus really had been like that, she would have been among those who were crying out, “Give us Barabbas!” Flipping this observation around, as a friend of mine recently did, we should be able to tell that a Jesus movie had been really successful in portraying the Lord if half the crowds in the theaters wanted to crucify Him — and not for being such a milksop either, but rather because He was a dangerous firebrand. A really good Jesus movie would have a bipartisan bill denouncing it — called Save the American Dream Act — passing both houses of Congress handily in a rush to get it to the president’s desk.

But alas. And if you ask me why I am not holding my breath, I would simply say that we really do need to have a thoughtful discussion of the Second Commandment, one that gets past — har, har — surface appearances.

24
Leave a Reply

avatar
 
24 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
22 Comment authors
Bobby Fostergeorge canadyKeith KraskaMorneMike D'Virgilio Recent comment authors

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Seneca Griggs
Guest

Loved it – 

MWorrell
Guest
MWorrell

Still waiting for an average height, plainly unattractive, Jewish Jesus in one of these films. These Johnny Depp types just get in the way of the message, and it was the message – the Word – that ripped the world apart.

Seth B.
Guest
Seth B.

Can your recommend some reading concerning the subject of portrayals of Jesus, icons, etc.? I found Calvin’s a Treatise on Relics but that’s about it…

Desiree
Guest
Desiree

Love this. I am dreading the soft spoken gentle white Jesus. I kind of wish that my church wasn’t among those buying out theaters on opening night. My lack of enthusiasm about this evangelistic prospect (as it is being billed at my church, though none of the non-believers of my acquaintance would ever agree to go to such a film) reminds me of high school, where I was the lame one who wasn’t particularly inspired by the cheer squad’s antics during pep rallies.

Timothy Wood
Guest

Thanks for my new favorite quote:

“…my idea of an ecclesiastical relic is a Claymoor hanging in the narthex.”

You beat Chesterton by adopting Knox’s willingness to both bear and hang up the sword for the cross.

Whitney
Guest
Whitney

Couldn’t. agree. more. I felt so disappointed when I watched the trailer because more than anything I got the strange impression they seemed quite interested in baiting a strong female viewership using ye olde Hollywoode casting methods, which is weird to me because honestly, he looks a lot like a girl. And now with articles headlining (!) in the news titled, “Meet the Hunk Who Plays the New Jesus” …… eesh.

kyriosity
Member

I’m reminded of last week’s parish study, when we were reviewing the similarities between the stories of Absalom and Jesus, and one wag (who shall remain nameless, but she’s typing this comment) noted that Jesus is always depicted with long hair, too, just like Absalom!

Ben Bowman
Guest

Isn’t this the same production company and people who did the “Bible” mini series. Ugh, that was pretty awful. 

Robert
Guest
Robert

Most p;ictures of Jesus that are found in churches are based off of ancient artwork of Zeus.

Willis
Guest
Willis

I don’t think that the second commandment forbids portrayals of Jesus for instructional purposes. It is speaking about worship. 
With that being said, the movie does look pretty cheesy and the real Jesus would certainly offend. 

kyriosity
Member

“The Lord’s first command was ‘follow me,’ and so why do we always get these guys that you wouldn’t want to follow for ninety seconds on an escalator?”
                                                                                                                                                    
Far from following him, he’s got a puppy-eyed face that would be more likely to follow us home. “Can I keep him, Mom? Can I pleeeeease? I promise he won’t make a mess. He’s a nice, domesticated little Jesus!”

Michael Lynch
Guest
Michael Lynch

Ben, yes. 

antexw
Member

Bummer — another painting or motion picture about the Lord Jesus that isn’t consistent with the special revelation He gave through His apostle Paul in 1 Co 11:14, objectively declaring some content of natural revelation from God that has been instinctively/naturally (and thus, already subjectively) known to us through basic human nature/conscience.

duellsquimby
Member

I thought the best scenes in the movie were the ones ‘behind the scenes’, like the chief pharisee debating, or others.  However I kept getting the idea throughout, that they were trying to improve the story by changing  things that were obviously mentioned in the Bible or easily deducible, like the lions den that David was led into, and on the next day only the one guy tossed in by the king vs. the guy and his family.  My wife and I were critiquing the movie as we were going watching, we made it through the whole thing, and I… Read more »

Andrew Lohr
Member

Seth–“Seeing Jesus” by Jeffrey J. Meyers, about 50 pages on pictures of Jesus and so on, by PCA pastor in St Louis.  Probably available from Biblical Horizons; I got one there.  (Sorry I’m not linking; every click on blue print here tonight brings up an ad.)   Jeff surveys Reformation literature and thinks some pictures OK (pictures of Jesus doing something), but idolatry (worshiping the pictures) not, and some types of pictures tend to attract idolatry.    Me, since Jesus is a man of flesh and blood, and men can be pictured, I think pictures OK (denial of His flesh is serious… Read more »

kyriosity
Member

Andrew, it’s on YouTube. I’ve not seen it, either, but I was curious so I looked it up: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UW56Gf30Vfg

Jabberwooky
Guest
Jabberwooky

You’re such a crazy person.  What, you think Jesus was more like Mitt Romney than Russell Brand?

Bob in Maryland
Guest
Bob in Maryland

Which 2nd Commandment? The Catholic version (“Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in Vain”) or the Protestant one (“Thou shalt make no graven image”)?

Larry B
Guest
Larry B

Thank you for writing the very things I was thinking!

Mike D'Virgilio
Member
Mike D'Virgilio

I still think the best Jesus in cinema is Robert Powell in Franco Zeffirelli’s 1977 “Jesus of Nazareth.”  He was no Russell Brand!

Morne
Guest
Morne

If we had a movie that actually portrayed Jesus correctly we’ll have the religious community up in arms…um, wait a minute…ok, lets just stick to the second commandment critique.

Keith Kraska
Guest
Keith Kraska

WHGWJU: What Hair Gel Would Jesus Use?

george canady
Guest
george canady

What then is “Pilgrim’s Progress”? By the way, I lean with you on this.

Bobby Foster
Guest
Bobby Foster

I somehow think it is the message and the authority with which it was delivered, not the physical appearance, that made people want to follow Jesus. It could well be, that on first glance, Jesus may not have been someone you would have followed on an escalator. There are several depictions in film that I liked. Granted, perhaps not Max Von Sydow or the latest incarnation that you speak of above, but I don’t think you can discount all of them. someone already mentioned Robert Powell above, and I liked Jim Cavezel’s portrayal as well.