Contents
Classical Christian Liberalism
This struck a chord with something I’ve been puzzling on. Why do we have high gas prices when we make more oil then we use? Why do business outsource to save a few bucks on sub-par labor. Why is everyone everywhere looking for how they can implement “digital workers”? I think its because they don’t love their nation. An American company of long ago would have not laid its countryman on the altar, at least I don’t think. Being from long ago, was that the case?
And I don’t think you can love your nation and your countryman unless you love Jesus and have your sins forgiven. At least not in a way that doesn’t turn you into Gollum.
Thanks,Thomas
Thomas, while we have always had merchants who cut corners in ways that did not love the customer, the rise of ethical relativism has made it possible for the cutting of corners to be considered “best practices.” But on the question of the gas prices, I suspect government involvement, trying to make things better.
What Kind of Psalm Singing?
The defence of psalm-singing, such as you gave in a recent sermon, can be argued rather straightforwardly from Scripture. Christ sung psalms, Paul says we should, and God gave them to us to sing. It takes an extra step, more of a wisdom call, to claim that one particular style of music is better than others for psalm-singing. At least, it is difficult to do this without leaving yourself open to the counterclaim, “That’s just your opinion. I think this type of music is more psalm-like.”
Aside from the words you sing, how would you defend the type of music to which you sing it?
Kind regards,Micah
Micah, you are exactly right that the defense of musical style is not directly exegetical. That defense would need to be historical and aesthetic. But there is also a practical side. The entirety of the psalter is not available outside a certain musical tradition.
The Edge?

In a recent “Doug and Friends” episode Nate, when discussing the two bad options for Texas senate, called Ken Paxton a “dirtbag” and James Talarico a “pumpkin-headed gay boy.” Is this utilizing the serrated edge? Is this juvenile name-calling? Something else?
Thanks.Joel
Joel, I would take it as a summary of the electorate’s feelings.
Recent Sermon on Prayer
Two follow-up questions on the prayer sermon:
If we should confess our sins at the beginning of our prayers in order to get cleaned up before we pray other sorts of prayers, why does confession/request for forgiveness come near the end of the Lord’s prayer?
How do we avoid crossing the line from a prayer of authority to a prayer of presumption?
Thanks!Kyriosity
Kyriosity, your question about the placement of confession is a great one. In the Old Testament, when the three sacrifices—guilt, ascension, and peace—are mentioned together, the guilt offering comes first. But the Lord’s placement later does mean we shouldn’t make it into a rigid rule. I am inclined to think that we should confess our sins at the beginning of the service (if we haven’t confessed them already), and that as the service progresses we are mindful of ourselves, prepared to confess that the service brings things to mind. And on the difference between faith and presumption, my argument is that we learn the distinction through long and disciplined practice. Start where you are. Start when you are no good at it.
Thank you for your message on prayer. Short message but long in content. Timely message as I’m heading to church now.Jerry
Jerry, amen. You’re welcome. And may God bless it.
Women’s Ministry at Christ Church
At Christ Church, do the women’s ministries have appointed women leaders who teach (exegete) other women the Bible—verse by verse (for e.g. James 1:1-4), similar to the way sermons are preached?AA
AA, no, we don’t really have that. The center of our women’s ministry is women working shoulder to shoulder on matters related to hospitality and good works. The closest thing to your question would be various women’s book studies, where they go through a Puritan work together. The women work through books of the Bible on Sunday morning with everyone else.
Choosing Sides in an Ethnic War
You said: “You don’t have to choose sides in an ethnic war. The other side does that for you.”
When do you believe White Southerners first entered into an ethnic war, and whose choice was that?
Most people would think that the “Southern White Side” chose their side of the ethnic war around the time that they made slavery into a race-based institution. When forced by others to divest of that institution, they maintained their allegiance to their chosen side when they segregated every possible institution with power and then kept the power in those White institutions, which was official policy into living memory (including yours). So hadn’t “your side” already chosen their sides long before others chose it for you?
Again, they were forced by others to be less overt about segregation, but the immediate inauguration of “Segregation Academies” in the 1960s showed that the desire to maintain sides was still there. In my town, the segregation academy still exists and the schools remain almost entirely segregated. The churches remain almost entirely segregated. Most business and political power remains segregated. And in all of those cases, it really doesn’t seem that the “other side” chose that.
I, personally, as a White person, have never once felt like someone else chose my side in any ethnic war. I don’t think Jesus wants us to choose those sides, and so long as I honor Jesus, I’ve been very well-accepted by all ethnicities and they seem quite grateful that I’m not choosing the opposing side. Everyone who is on the “white side” of the ethnic war, at least here in my town, really seems to have chosen that side for themselves or had it chosen by their ancestors and now struggle personally to divest of what it brings them.Koinonia Anon
Koinonia Anon, everything you say about the history of this mess is quite correct. The root cause of our current black/white ethnic tension was the choice to import black slaves. But the Civil Rights Act was the beginning of a great bait-and-switch repentance. It was sold as the abandonment of the ways of all such bigotry when it was really just everybody switching the direction the same sin was flowing. For more, read Jeremy Carl’s The Unprotected Class and Coldwell’s Age of Entitlement.
I think everybody is missing a really big factor in the election conversation . . . everyone is utterly retarded. The men are effeminate and very proud of themselves for shooting themselves in the foot, and we all know what a nuclear explosion feminism has been. Reading comprehension is in the toilet, if people are even lucky enough to be able to sound out words at all.
What should Christians be doing? Raising your family right and going to church matters, obviously, but we’re commanded to go out into the world, too. What are some practical things people could be doing to help with this mess? Christians need to stop LARPing on the internet and get out there. I think that’s a skill that’s been lost. What do we do?HL, aka Motivated
HL, agreed. What we do is plant churches, and worship in them. Start Christian schools. Get our kids out of the government schools. Start businesses, serve the public. Wait on the Lord. Cry out to Him.
Family Authority
I’m writing you for an advice. My husband would like to have some sort of a veto in our marriage. I’m more on the side of being it 50/50 split, but lately there were too many arguments and deadlocks about important matters like future location of our new house, voting and more.
To solve this, he proposed he would get a veto so we can finally move forward. But he didn’t really explain it to me in detail. Why him, and not me? Based on what, really? I understand it is in the Bible. but I’d appreciate more in-depth explanation, why is it there in the first place. What makes a Man the leader? Based on what facts? And what would be so poor about me being the leader as well?
I’m a woman who can reason and compromise. I don’t see myself limited or making worse decisions than a man. But I’m also willing to learn and see I might be wrong about this.
Thank you for your time!
Warm regards,Alexandria
Alexandria, I would offer two things. First, George MacDonald once said that obedience is the great opener of eyes. If you know it is in the Bible, the key to understanding the reasons for it will begin with obedience. Practice it first. Learn submission first. Having done so brings you to the second thing. If it was you and not him, then he could write the letter of complaint. Why her and not me? A marriage has two people in it. When they are agreed, which should be most of the time, there is no issue. But when they differ, someone has to decide, and God determined that it should be the husband. There is joy in submitting to that.
Steve’s letter said his wife refuses submission. He supported that conclusion by claiming she intentionally does the opposite of his stated wishes, that she chooses to not work but watch television, that she is willing to spend money he earns.
Steve wrote that the elders concluded he had a tough situation and that they did not know what to do. Steve’s letter does not provide any information regarding how the elders reached either of those conclusions.
Possibly Steve’s original letter had information about what the elders did or did not do that the published letter does not. Or it mentioned that the wife is neither a professing Christian nor a church member. Yet it seems to me that your counsel to Steve assumed the elders of his church will not do what the Bible says they can do and ought to do. In any case, I wish your reply noted that your (otherwise wise) counsel was based on that assumption.
Meanwhile, the elders (and your readers) actually ought know there is plenty elders can do. They are not helpless, but teachers with the message of a redeeming King (Mt 28:20), his counselors (Ro 15:14). Their office qualifies them for precisely the kind of involvement Steve and his wife need.
Per, eg, Pr 18:17, the elders can/ought verify the accuracy of Steve’s evaluation. (Does the wife agree with Steve? Or is her story different?) If Steve’s story errs, they can/ought help him understand where he errs and what changes God expects him to work on together with his wife. If Steve is accurate, they can/ought counsel her. This would involve their finding out whether she needs to hear the Gospel, whether she knows what the Bible says about her choices and teaching her if she does not. Does she hear and understand, then hear the Bible, repent, and do what the it says? (“hearing” implying a process that might take a while) If so, then she, Steve, and the elders can thank God for loving leaders. But if she refuses to hear, the elders can/ought warn her of the disasters her sin might bring. She needs to know they are witnesses of her refusal, that they support Steve’s understanding. Also as custodians of the keys to the kingdom, they can/ought warn her that her continuing her path could and will lead to their censuring her for refusing to obey scripture and thus demonstrating she does not belong to Christ.Roy
Roy, thanks. Good letter.
Miscarriage
I recently had a miscarriage which would have been our fourth child. I have been assured of God’s love, comfort, providence, and mercy in this even as I have mourned. My question is about how to go on from here. What is a biblical way forward after a loss of a loved one, especially in miscarriage or the loss of a young child? I’ve seen parents continually reminding others of their loss, and I’ve seen parents who don’t want to bring it up at all or seem to think nothing of it; neither of these options strike me as “appropriate.” (Or am I just being too critical?) What I really want to know is what pitfalls to avoid going forward.
Thank you.Rebecca
Rebecca, the way forward is to mourn the wound, like a Christian, and then to let the wound heal, also like a Christian. Don’t keep the wound bleeding.
The Abusing of Harmeet
In the wake of her resignation, a lot of men who claim to be Christian Nationalists have been showing their ingratitude toward Harmeet Dhillon’s excellent service by taunting her over being a Sikh, calling her a “Demon worshiper.” Sikhs are not Abrahamic, but is it really biblically fair to characterize a monotheist as a “demon worshiper?” Were she a polytheist or a worshiper of territorial gods, that would seem to me to be a fair charge, but I’m not comfortable with characterizing any monotheist as a demon worshiper (yes, even the monotheists whose customary chant of “Allahu Akbar” is characteristically followed by a loud and murderous explosion).Daniel
Daniel, the way she has been taunted has been disgusting. “For ye have brought hither these men, which are neither robbers of churches, nor yet blasphemers of your goddess” (Acts 19:37). That is not the way, even when demons are involved. We are to oppose every false way, but we are to do so in the apostolic way.
A Laymen’s Duties
What responsibility or duty does a layman in the church have to hold his elders accountable, especially when it comes to keeping the church constitution?Timothy
Timothy, when he notices something, his responsibility is to ask questions about it. He should listen carefully to the answers, prepared to accept them. If the answers are inadequate, he should write a formal letter to session, registering his concerns. If the problem continues, he should vote for new elders, or not, based on the issue. If the problem is egregious and unaddressed, it may be time to leave the church.
In the CREC constitution, it seems a bar is set of “grievous dishonesty or gross misbehavior” as the standard for which a charge should be considered against an elder. How would you define the terms grievous dishonesty and gross misbehavior? What standard do you use to know whether a behavior has risen to the levels of grievous or gross?James
James, the phrase was meant convey a situation of the highest seriousness. Think of “high crimes and misdemeanors.” The grievous dishonesty would be with regard to confessional standards, saying you believed the Bible was infallible when you didn’t. And gross misbehavior would be something like slapping the wrist of a church officer who had committed adultery.
Women in the Military
Women in the military, is there a place for it? I have disagreed with the majority of my family on this topic and hits directly to home as my sister recently joined and is of marriage and child bearing age. I’m open to being wrong but would appreciate a more biblically supported answer so as to be best informed. Thanks so much.Allison
Allison, I believe there is a place for women in the military, but only in certain specified support roles—nurses, secretarial, etc. No combat roles, and nothing resembling a combat role.
Another Country Heard From
I think you may be Zeus. Also known as Odin. You look like him. I’m also pretty sure you were my father in a few lifetimes. My name is Bre. I am also known as Lilith and Persephone. Any thoughts?Bre
Bre, yes. I have quite a few thoughts.
Tight Harmonies
A song I like for some reason. You might as well.Jason
Jason, thanks.
Whiteness
In your recent article “The Unbearable Whiteness of Being,” you make state the following:
It is possible to understand two things together at the same time. The first is that American Christian culture is under assault and is worth defending, and second, that whiteness, as a stand-alone characteristic, is not an ethnicity.
You then follow this up, saying:
And you can understand that whiteness is not an ethnicity while still understanding that whiteness is under attack everywhere. You can be in a battle, and still keep your head.
You can fight for what is right without turning into everything that is wrong.
My question is, when you say that whiteness is not an ethnicity, what do you mean by that (as opposed to what someone like Webbon would say)? For my part, it seems pretty clear that while whiteness completely by itself is not an ethnicity, we regularly use the term as short-hand for a genuine ethnic group, namely WASPs. When one says refers to a white person, or to white culture, they are most immediately thinking of Anglo-Protestant culture, which has historically been the dominant culture within the USA, as opposed to Italians or Cajuns or Irish, etc. Even those groups, which all have white skim, are normed by their assimilation into the broader Anglo-Protestant culture.
I assume that you don’t disagree with any of what I’ve just written, which brings me back to my question. When you say “whiteness as a stand-alone characteristic is not an ethnicity,” what do you mean by that, and how is that different from what someone like Webbon is arguing for?
God Bless,A Normie WASP
Normie WASP, yes. When we say “white culture,” in our context it is shorthand for something, and it is something identifiable. But globally it is wildly inaccurate. A Romanian is every bit as white as I am, but belongs to an entirely different ethnicity. I want to fight to keep American culture, which has been predominantly white, but don’t want to fight to institute German culture, which is also predominantly white. Treating “white” like a tribe just confuses things, and makes it easier for bigots to vent their spleen.
Censoring Bible?
This past year, my wife and I have begun reading through the Bible with our children one chapter at a time as part of our bedtime routine. We read through some difficult passages already but as we are about to start Judges and are thinking about those last couple chapters, I am wondering if there is wisdom in paraphrasing some of the more graphic depictions in the Bible. My children are 7, 5, 3, and 7 (lol).
On one hand, it is the words of the Lord and I don’t want to muffle them. On the other, I know we will cover it directly when they are more mature. And yet, isn’t that how we mature, through learning some of the darker things of God world and His story in it?
Would love to hear your thoughts!Stephen
Stephen, different households will make different decisions on this, but since you are asking me, I would go right ahead.
The Brilliance of Ancient Man
You know what else is brilliant? The essay “I, Pencil.” And lo and behold there it is right in the middle of a Young Earther post. Fabulous! I did not wake up expecting to see that as a category on the ol’ Jeopardy board. “I’ll take 1950s essays on economics embedded in an antediluvian blog entry for 800 please Alex . . .
Thanks Doug, I can’t express in words the chortle my soul gave having read this post.Ryan
Ryan, thank you.
A Sad Slide
My normally discerning Christian husband has fallen into some true hyper patriarchal/red pill stuff—withdrawals emotionally, hides things, requires obedience to his “standard,” punishes me (not physically) if I do something wrong—this looks like ignoring me or not talking to me or sleeping on the couch, he stopped listening to my opinions on things and treats me as a second class citizen or a slave in our marriage. This is completely opposite than how he treated me even six months ago—which was so amazing and I felt so loved and cherished. He had read a couple secular masculine books that steered him this way and “opened up his eyes” to how I was actually acting in charge (which isn’t actually true:(). Anyways, he still takes us to church but he refuses to talk with our pastor or others about these issues, and has stopped talking to some of his best friends bc of all this. What do I do? I guess just 1 Peter 3? And hope and pray that repentance comes?Anon
Anon, yes. 1 Pet. 3. But something else happened, and it wasn’t just the books he read. You be praying over your interactions prior to that point, asking the Lord to reveal to you where the root of bitterness began. It may be something he did, or something you did. But God knows what it is, and you can ask Him.
Burnt by Bad Patriarchy
What would you recommend a husband do whose wife grew up Reformed Baptist, with strong teaching on headship/submission, but saw a lot of genuine, serious abuse (including physical abuse that somehow got justified by headship/submission) in her church, which has led her to be a cautiously submissive wife—quick to pull the ripcord. She assents to the doctrine, but in application likes to use a lot of language about “us deciding” and doesn’t love decisive leadership from me. I think she tries to be submissive but it doesn’t come naturally to her (fiery, big personality) and talking about headship/submission triggers a lot of stuff from her old church. There are some big life decisions coming up, and I’m afraid when push comes to shove, if she were to disagree with me on them, even after lengthy discussion and prayer, she would not submit.
I want to be a good head and lead well. I sin like any man, am selfish sometimes in my leadership, but it seems that even the smallest sin like that “resets the clock” and I am working to (gently) reassert authority. Decisiveness also doesn’t come naturally to me—although I have made great strides the past few years. I guess what I’m asking is, how do I grow in good leadership/decisiveness/genuinely leading my household (and feeling like I’m leading my household), while still being gentle towards my wife in this area because of her background with this stuff? And how do I help her grow in submissiveness?
I’ve read Federal Husband, and, while excellent, didn’t give me the specific handles I need to grab this theology and carry it with me.
Respectfully,Anon
Anon, this is a tough one. The first thing to realize is that she might not have an entirely accurate view of what happened in her church growing up—although bad patriarchy certainly does exist. The main thing for you is to exercise authority in your prayers to God. You have big decisions coming up. Work through them carefully in your prayers, long before your first conversation with her.
Sorry, I Don’t
I was wondering if you have any recommendations for teaching students how to debate? Books or curriculum?
Thanks,Alesha
Alesha, sorry, I don’t. I wish I did though.
Modern Geneva
In past posts you’ve criticized commercial publishers for treating the church as a consumer demographic while academics and businessmen control Bible translations and copyrights. Given that Canon Press (a private, for-profit company) owns the copyright to the Modernized Geneva Bible and receives the profits from its sales, how does the MGB project differ from the “Bible-mongery” you’ve previously objected to? What is the proper role of the church versus a private publishing house in producing and owning a Bible translation? And are there any updates on the single volume MGB?
Thanks for all you do!Josh
Josh, the copyright is to protect the version from distortions from others, but not to prevent quotation and legitimate use. We are working on approach to church involvement prior to the publication of the OT. In other words, Canon is actively working on it.
Apologies
I grabbed ND’s “The Dragon’s Tooth” on the first day of the physical book giveaways. I assumed I would be able to take a shot at grabbing 1 copy of each of the giveaways (if I got to it in time), but after trying to grab one of the CanonBall books today, I got this message: “A free giveaway book has already been claimed for this household or email during this giveaway (limit one per household). Remove the free book to continue, or contact Canon Press if this is a mistake.”
I just want to confirm: does this mean I’m “out” for the rest of the physical giveaways (since I already got 1 book), or was this a mistake? Just want to know ahead of the next round of giveaways on Wednesday!Ben
Ben, very sorry. That was not a mistake. We are trying to spread the goodness, and so the limit is one physical book per customer, per November.
Willingness to be Lost
You recently wrote something about husbands being willing to go to Hell for their wives, per Romans 9:3. I believe Romans 9 is a chapter where we must be careful to use the exact language that Paul uses without importing our shortcuts. Paul does not say he would go to Hell for the Jews—he says he could wish to be accursed from Christ for them.
Jesus Himself became a curse for us (Galatians 3:13), separated from His Father (Matthew 27:46), but this does not mean that Jesus was eternally damned, nor that He was willing to be. Jesus knew from the beginning that this was for the joy set before Him (Hebrews 12:2). Husbands, likewise, are to love their wives in the same way: for the joy set before them (Ephesians 5:25-30). Dying for her, yes. Damnation for her, no. Surely Paul has not forgotten Philippians 3, that in being conformed to Christ’s death, he is leaning into His resurrection.
Jesus Himself tells us over and over again that we will gain our lives when we lose them. He is not opposed to us having hope for ourselves and for others when we die for them. Being willing to be damned just doesn’t square with any of this.
Moses, too, tends to be taken out of context. He asked God to blot him out of His book if He will not forgive the Israelites, and in OT context, that means “kill me,” not “send me to Hell.” The book of life was temporal (Psalm 139:16).
Dying daily for my wife is hard enough. I’m going to work on that without worrying about checking my motives to see if I am willing to go to Hell for her.
Even so, great post, Pastor Wilson—thank you for the reminder and conviction!Andrew
Andrew, thanks for the response. I have long said that we cannot duplicate Christ’s death on the cross for His people, but we are commanded to imitate it. It is the same kind of thing here. Paul says “for I could wish,” which I take as a hypothetical. “If it were possible” (but it isn’t), I would volunteer to take her place. But I can’t . . . but I can wish I could. It is not possible, and no finite creature in this life can understand damnation, and so I take your point. If I wished that I could, I grant that I would not understand that wish. But it is still good to wish it.

