The Bottom Line for the Impatient
In order for classical liberalism to survive, its advocates must call upon Christ. They must stop being ashamed of Him—and this, if it happens, will make classical liberalism a particular form of Christian nationalism. At the same time, in order to prevent Christian nationalists from veering off into untethered kookery, as some are attempting even now, they must learn to accept the grace of God that has been classical liberalism. Otherwise they are going to run out of money.
By this I do not mean classical liberalism without Christ. That is just bankrupt secularism. Neither do I mean Christian nationalism without Christ, the kind that shouts “Christ is king” with their lips but with their hearts all tangled up in Sturm und Drang conferences. That is just bankrupt lamesauce. A five gallon bucket of lamesauce.
Introduction
A perennial problem of the left, an affliction that cripples them of necessity, is their dogged belief that the state needs to be understood as a reservoir of goodies, to be dispensed to the deserving and well-connected. The reason it is crippling is that, as Margaret Thatcher put it, sooner or later you run out of other people’s money.

But in recent years, this attitude has been a developing problem on the right as well, with the only difference being who is considered deserving, and who happens to be well-connected. The government is thought to be simply this gigantic ATM machine—and all our political fights are over who has the right to control the passwords in order to access the (apparently bottomless) account.
Those who still understand the means by which any funds wind up in the account in the first place are dismissed as hopeless fogies, as people who don’t understand “what time it is.” Now to be fair to those on the right who mount this criticism, there are a lot of free market aficionados don’t understand what time it is. And therein lies my tale.
Although it is not really a tale. More a line of argument, topped off with some balanced fulminations. Balanced, but nevertheless unqualified. These are novembric times, remember.
Classical Liberalism
Adam Smith famously described the mechanism of markets for us. A society is much more likely to prosper long term when individuals are left free to pursue their own self-interest. It is possible for social benefits to emerge that no one individual or agency ever intended or planned. It just happens, as though an invisible hand were guiding it to that magical result. Thus the wisest course of action is to limit government’s role in the market, and to cultivate a climate that encourages such decentralized and self-interested actions without any centralized control or design. Just do this, and the whole society prospers and grows.
“It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.”
Adam Smith
Now Smith was not an anarchist, but when it came to the production, sale, and distribution of any lawful widgets, gadgets, thingummies, or pins, he was a minarchist. Not only so, but he has been proven right in countless ways. This is exactly what happens. This is exactly how you get multiple goods to the most people over the longest period of time.
Now looking down the corridor we are in for just a minute, I am going to be arguing shortly that they do have to be a certain kind of people. This is because there is a difference between long term self-interest and short term self-interest. All people are motivated by self-interest, true enough. But there is self-interest and there is self-interest.
But if you leave the right kind of people to their own devices, then that busy intersection on the south of town will have four gas stations, one on each corner. The waste, the redundancies, and the irrationality of it all exasperates the tidy-minded socialist, that great admirer of planning and efficiency. There should only be one gas station there, he thinks, and after the revolution that is exactly how many we will have. One clean, orderly, and efficient gas station . . . but of course, no gas. Karl Marx apparently anticipated this “no gas” problem in Das Kapital when he famously said, “Well, you can’t have everything.”
So that’s what the invisible hand of the market does. Provides you with the gas, and all the other stuff, including the snacks inside the gas stations.
Provided, of course . . .
What Markets Cannot Do
Free and untrammeled markets can work wonders. They can fetch me tangerines in the middle of winter, they can deliver computing power that is cheaper and cheaper by the year, they can fly me across the country in mere hours and, as they say on the teevee, much, much more. If I wanted to, I could buy a fifty pound bag of almonds at Costco.
But there is one thing the invisible hand cannot do. It cannot write a book that will make all the diehard socialists slap their own foreheads, exclaiming in remorse, “Why didn’t I see this before!” To be sure, such books do get written . . . but they don’t produce the kind of people who can understand them. The market produces the books, but not the readers.
There are various ways of stating this. Just as healthy tissue cannot defend itself against cancer, markets cannot defend themselves from socialism. This is because prosperity is not the medicine for envy; it is rather one of the central causes of envy.
Markets cannot explain the foundation of markets—because free men are the foundation of free markets. And, as long as they are in the grip of a secular classical liberalism, free marketeers cannot adequately explain any of this. This is because secularists cannot account for sin.
Free markets do not create free men. Free markets create prosperity, and prosperity creates slaves. So the process has to go the other way. It runs in the opposite direction. Free men create free markets, and you cannot have free men without Jesus Christ.
Slaves to sin do not build free societies. Slaves to sin are not the architects of economic liberty. Free societies can only be built and sustained by virtuous men, and virtuous men are always in short supply apart from the gospel.
Free market economists can explain how markets work, and they can describe in excruciating detail how collectivism doesn’t. What the secular defender of markets cannot do is explain why we should seek the greatest good for the greatest number. And they cannot explain how we might obtain the kind of people who would be willing to follow their free market arguments. They cannot explain how we could possibly grow the kind of people who will turn away from all that “free stuff” socialism with disgust.
Take Adam Smith’s “self-interest,” for example. There is the self-interest that understands the long term value of deferred gratification, and there is the self-interest of the short term thinker, who understands where to find his meth dealer. Both of them are acting in line with what they believe to be their own interest. But the former understands the blessing that comes from discipline and virtue. The latter understands the pleasure that comes from feeding his habit. But discipline and virtue are not generated by the market. Rather, the market is generated by discipline and virtue.
So classical liberalism does in fact produce prosperity. What it also produces is boatloads of people who don’t understand where the prosperity comes from. People who grow up in the midst of abundance are prime candidates for being suckered in this way.
“But Jeshurun waxed fat, and kicked: Thou art waxen fat, thou art grown thick, thou art covered with fatness; Then he forsook God which made him, and lightly esteemed the Rock of his salvation.”Deuteronomy 32:15 (KJV)
Or as Cotton Mather put it, “faithfulness begat prosperity and the daughter devoured the mother.”
Classical Liberals Need Jesus
This is why my version of Christian nationalism is essential to the continued existence of classical liberalism. Christian nationalism, by definition, is the foe of every form of secularism. Christian nationalism, understood rightly, is the friend of liberty. More than that, it is the foundation of liberty. This includes economic liberty. Put another way, in order for classical liberalism to remain classical liberalism, it has to become classical Christian liberalism.
There are two ways to respond to the corruptions that have grown up in our current system. One is to look at those corruptions and declare that they are the necessary fruit of what is called “capitalism,” and say that we need a strong man to deliver us from our economic woes. We need a man with a plan, or with enough charisma to make us all think he has a plan. This is the trap that some on the right are falling into.
One of the reasons they are falling for it is that we call our current system “capitalism,” when it is actually a hybrid mash-up. It used to be a free market system, but the statist encroachments have been steady and unrelenting. The end result is that our government is way more involved in the market than it ought to be. All these business/state “partnerships” are, at their best, a cozy form of corruption, and at their worst, fascism. It is not capitalism—I call it crapitalism. And it won’t stop being crapitalism just because you put a Protestant strong man in charge of it.
So the markets are not failing us. Manipulated markets are failing us, true enough. Jiggered markets are not doing the trick, I gladly acknowledge. Over-regulated industries are failing to deliver the goods, as should have been anticipated.
Trust the Invisible Hand
The way out of our economic doldrums is to trust the invisible hand. Aye, but there’s the rub. Whose hand is it? Is that hand attached to an arm? So those who would actually defend free markets need either to become Christians, or they need to bring their Christianity along with them whenever they are thinking or talking about the economy.
We are not blessed by impersonal forces. We are blessed by God, and by God I mean the living God.
“Beware that thou forget not the Lord thy God, in not keeping his commandments, and his judgments, and his statutes, which I command thee this day: Lest when thou hast eaten and art full, and hast built goodly houses, and dwelt therein; And when thy herds and thy flocks multiply, and thy silver and thy gold is multiplied, and all that thou hast is multiplied; Then thine heart be lifted up, and thou forget the Lord thy God . . .”Deut. 8:11–14a (KJV)
If men are made to think that the forces making all of this happen are impersonal forces, who are they going to go with? That impersonal force, first cousin to electricity or gravity? Or the very personal demagogue, the one who feels your pain, and promises to send you a bunch of free stuff? So this is why classical liberals need to repent of their secularism. Secularism is the enemy of free markets. Secularism is a broken reed ally.
The reactionary bros on the right need to repent also. They need to cease with their fatuous fascination with strong man economics. A Protestant Franco—a glorious mash-up of Althusius, Solomon, and Charlemagne—could not run the economy of one square mile of Brooklyn. The only thing a strong man could do would be to cudgel an economy into stagnation. That is within our capacity.
This is why political and economic reform has to be both top-down—wise leadership—and bottom-up—a virtuous people. Both of these conditions require a lot more gospel preaching than we currently have. And it needs to be gospel preaching that names the name of Christ. Anything else will be stop-gapping with makeshifts.
Another way of putting this is that the people need to believe that all of this apparently unplanned activity is somehow going to land right side up. And when you are called upon to believe something as counterintuitive as that, a good name for such people would be believers.
I have friends who want me to stop using the label Christian nationalism. I am not prepared to do that, not at all, but what would be some good alternatives? One friend suggested Christian federalism, which I like. But I also like this one, because it is cheeky—classical Christian liberalism. It has a nice ring.
Today’s Giveaways
Over the course of the next five days, the Canon Press free Kindle giveaway is The Serrated Edge (2nd Ed.). You can get that fine book here. And new this year, for NQN Vol. 9 we have started giving away actual books—all you pay for is the shipping. Today’s hardback giveaway is my book for parenting in an age sentimental and therapeutic goo, Keep Your Kids. Quantities are limited, and you can only pick one free book, so get in line at noquarternovember.com.
As far as the Mablog Shoppe is concerned, today’s giveaway is Smashmouth Incrementalism, which will remain free for the rest of the month. So will the earlier giveaways.


