Banner
21 Questions for a Prospective Suitor PDF Print E-mail
Written by Douglas Wilson   
Wednesday, March 28, 2007 11:23 am

A father in my congregation has asked me what sort of questions a father should be asking a young man who wants to court his daughter. It is one thing to affirm that fathers should be active in protecting their daughters, but it is quite another to figure out what sort of specific questions are appropriate to ask. I compile this list as a father of two young women, now safely married, and as a pastor who frequently gives counsel to young men before they announce their interests and intentions. A list of questions like this ought not to be use in a wooden checklist fashion, but rather as a list of ideas to get started.

1. Tell me about your spiritual background. What was your church upbringing like? At what point did your spiritual experience become real to you? Have you ever had a period of spiritual rebellion?

2. When was the last time you read through the entire Bible? The New Testament?

3. Do you attend worship every Lord's Day?

4. Describe your parents' marriage for me. What are the most valuable lessons you have you learned from your parents? [In cases of divorce, or other severe marriage problems] What did you learn from these problems? Have you learned what not to do? [In cases where dad wronged mom] What did you do to support and encourage your mother?

5. What is your relationship like with your dad? With your mom?

6. If I were given a fly-on-the-wall glimpse of a typical conversation that you might have with your mom, would you agree that this will likely be the way you will be treating my daughter ten years from now? Why or why not?

7. How many brothers and sisters do you have? How do you get along them?

8. What kind of worker are you?

9. How many jobs have you had in your life, and what did your bosses think of you? Were those bosses sorry to see you go, or glad to see you go?

10. What do you believe God has called you to do vocationally? Ten years from now, what you believe you will be doing?

11. What steps have you taken to reach that goal?

12. What was your GPA in college? How come?

13. How much money did you make last year? Do you pay your bills on time? How much debt have you accumulated? Please describe the nature of your debts (student loans, car, house, credit cards, or expensive porn sites).

14. Speaking of porn sites, do you have a problem with pornography?

15. If you do, please describe the nature and extent of the problem. [It is important here for fathers to distinguish between the kind of periodic struggles that a normal young man is likely to have had, and the kind of obsessive behavior that indicates much deeper problems, such as contempt for women or an addictive lack of self control. Marriage is likely to fix the first kind of "normal" problem, and will only exacerbate the second kind of pathological problem.]

16. Is there anything in your sexual history that I need to know about? Failed marriage? Live-in girl friend two years before you became a Christian? Live-in girl friend six months after you became a Christian? Got three girls pregnant in high school?

17. Have you ever participated, whether experimentally or otherwise, in any sexual perversions? Homosexuality? Molestation of children? Bestiality?

18. Have you ever been in any kind of trouble with the law?

19. If I were to drop in to visit you at your apartment this afternoon, what would I find? A together sort of place? A clean place? The abomination of desolation?

20. Describe my daughter to me. What do you think she is like?

21. What about her do you find most attractive? You obviously believe that she would be a blessing to you. Why do you think you would be a blessing to her?



Add this page to your favorite Social Networking websites
Digg! Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! MySpace! Yahoo! BlogRolling! Twitter! LinkedIn! TwitThis
Last Updated on Wednesday, March 28, 2007 11:23 am
 
Comments
Search
Only registered users can write comments!
Jeffrey M. Jones  Wednesday, March 28, 2007 12:19 pm
Pastor Wilson,

Can you make a list for the girls. I have 3 young guys who will need a list for the women.

Jeff
Edward Aldridge  Wednesday, March 28, 2007 1:35 pm
Pastor Wilson, do you intend this list to be covered before courtship begins? I'm interested to see your response to Jeffrey, mainly because it seems the list is more apt within the context of the courtship, not before. Obviously the roles are different, but no young man would ever dream of running a woman through a similar list before even asking to court her.
John Simmons  Wednesday, March 28, 2007 1:51 pm
I got married later in life at 35, but I wouldn't have even asked my wife out if I wasn't already thinking she would probably make a good wife.
Gabriel Martini  Wednesday, March 28, 2007 2:19 pm
These are interesting questions, but I wonder how many dads would actually be gracious to guys who struggle with sin in their life as opposed to how many would "fly off the handle" at the first sin exposed in the poor young man's life? It seems that something like this *could* give the impression that only sinless perfection is acceptable for their daughter -- a girl who is most assuredly a sinner. Where does the balance or discernment come in?
Robert Seward  Wednesday, March 28, 2007 2:34 pm
You might want to amend #4 just a little bit. If a young man comes from a family where the mother is the family destroyer, that would open a whole kettle of fish concerning his relationship with her and with women in general. When the father is the destroyer, you might want to ask what kind of relationship that he has with his father. I don't see this as the same thing as the question #5.
Shannon Moeller  Thursday, March 29, 2007 1:04 am
Mr. Martini: As an imperfect single 22-year-old young man, I would not be taken aback by being asked these questions by a potential father-in-law. Some of the questions would be harder to answer than others, but this seemed like a really fair and balanced list. It would be my hope that a father would not use these questions like a bridge troll, but as a careful guardian who was once an imperfect 22-year-old young man himself. The way I see it, the balance and discernment comes in the application, not the existence, of the list.
Craig Phelps  Thursday, March 29, 2007 1:10 am
Rev. Wilson, this is a great list that I wish would more often get up from the page and get some exercise. Fellers, I am 100per with Rev. Wilson here on this post and all I can say is the best thing is to do is to suck in that gut, be willing for the answer to be yes OR no, and above all by faith alone in Christ alone as your only righteousness before God commit your way to Him.
Valerie (Kyriosity)  Thursday, March 29, 2007 2:55 am
I can picture a certain friend's eyes rolling as she says, "You can see Doug Wilson's educational assumptions leaking through, especially on question 12!" Perhaps a more general inquiry into what kind of student the young man was would be of more use to those for whom college is not de rigueur. Of course the idea is to learn whether he's a diligent worker or a loafer, but you also want to discern if he's someone who values education for the right reasons, and isn't just good at intellectual pursuits in a formal institional structure.
Frank Turk  Thursday, March 29, 2007 4:59 am
What if the young man had a radical salvation experience about 10 months before he met your daughter, and his answers are, um, disappointing? For the record, that would have been me ...
Douglas Wilson  Thursday, March 29, 2007 5:50 am
Frank, the conversion is part of the story. A big part. I would rather have that, and bad answers to the questions, than good answers with no conversion.

At the same time, a wise father will want to know that the conversion "took."
Phil Hobbs  Thursday, March 29, 2007 6:08 am
Good list. I'd want to add something about drug and alcohol abuse, both in the family and his personally.
The Burly Gates  Thursday, March 29, 2007 6:19 am
22. What's in your Netflix queue?




And if there's anything "..Gone Wild" in there, you might have to kindly decline the chap.
The Burly Gates  Thursday, March 29, 2007 6:30 am
Seriously though, this is a great and timely list for me. Well, "timely" in the sense of target="_blank">18 years from now..
David Noor  Thursday, March 29, 2007 6:33 am
As an unmarried, 18-year-old, thoroughly flawed man, I would expect and hope to be asked questions like these by the father of my future bride. Rare jewels should be guarded with extreme care. In fact, if her father didn't ask some good, tough questions like these before letting me begin to court his daughter, I would be rather worried. The time to figure out whether or not a young man is committed to victory in the Christian life is definitely before he is allowed to get to know the young lady on a closer basis.
Gabriel Martini  Thursday, March 29, 2007 7:44 am
Yeah, that's what I meant by balance -- Some sort of disclaimer or exhortation about HOW to administer these questions to a potential suitor, and how to react when you find out -- *gasp* -- he's not perfect. I say this out of experience with some ill-balanced fathers in this area, who were admittedly, legalistic to begin with. *shrug*
chasid  Thursday, March 29, 2007 2:48 pm
Why no questions about the man's charity? Is that not a male virtue?
lewsta  Thursday, March 29, 2007 6:03 pm
Chasid, I rather took the queries relating to how the chap gets on with his parents to be in that category. Should he see Mum to be an old shrew, and Dad a bothersome blathering old fool, I should rather think he's failed at his vetting. On the other hand, if Mum is a sweetheart to him, and he's often on about caring for her tenderly, the putative Father in Law can rest assured the lad will similarly care for his daughter. Too, if he relates to his own Pater as a wise and trusted friend, PFIL might well be assured the chap in question will likely be able to hear instruction, seek safety in a multitude of counsel, and follow hard after widsom AND her source. Some time past I rather wish a certain gentleman HAD made use of such a list--instead I received a rather perfunctory dismissal, something about "unequally yoked" with no further explanation. I found myself wondering on what information, and in what category, he made his decision. Curious, that.....
chasid  Thursday, March 29, 2007 8:15 pm
I was thinking almsgiving in particular. Mother-father relations say a lot, but I think an inquiry into whether a man puts his money into the furtherance of the gospel will shed important light that cannot be revealed by his familial relations alone. Sure, charity can be faked, but so can sexual purity. Just a thought.
lewsta  Friday, March 30, 2007 5:14 am
Ah, Chasid, I get your aim now. I was considering "charity" in the far larger sense. There is the old saw "charity begins at home". If a man is free with his hand of giving at home, he will be when at large, as well. If he looks well to the needs of his parents and siblings, and his neighbours as well, he demonstrates a pattern of selflessness..or, at the least, a hand that is not tight when it comes to helping those in need. I would also certainly include TIME alongside gold when it comes to the furtherance of the gospel. Is he at all given to investing his time and energy into, say, short term missions, local service projects, as helping the elderly, prison and shut-in visitation, fundraising events for crisis pregnancy centres, and the like. As to faking it, I find that the giving of one's time and energy is often far more costly than simply posting a cheque toward a "worthy cause". Also, is he actively involved in his local church, readily working alongside others toward the common expression in the community? Or does he simply make an appearance Lord's Day morning, put in his "due" and depart as quickly as he can?
Robert Seward  Saturday, March 31, 2007 1:29 pm
The only sad thing about this discussion is that such a large percentage of the young Christian men and women in this country do not have fathers around, courtesy of divorce. I guess that is why we are working so hard to restore what whe have lost as well as bringing in new converts.
Mike Harkin  Monday, April 02, 2007 3:10 am
From Gabriel – “I say this out of experience with some ill-balanced fathers in this area, who were admittedly, legalistic to begin with.” But look how much you learned in that process? Instead of waiting till after the marriage, you get to see, up close and personal, what your future father-in-law is truly like. Is he gracious (yet firm) or a self-righteous bully? Fathers need to remember that they also are on the “hot seat”. A wise young man looks just as closely at a young girl’s parents, as he does her.
Harry  Thursday, April 05, 2007 7:01 am
I believe the idea of courtship to be completely ludircous. I could see a father wanting to protect his daughter but these questions are over the top.
cassie  Wednesday, April 25, 2007 3:44 pm
So good! I'm sending this to all my girlfriends' dads.
jon  Wednesday, July 25, 2007 2:08 pm
wow. psycho. Whoever wrote this list is way, way out of touch with reality. Here is a kooky idea, instead of making up absurd lists of questions that no one would answer honestly, why not spend time with your potential son-in-law and get to know his true nature.

Way to segue between debt and porn. Real subtle. This list is too over the top to be for real.
Danette  Thursday, December 11, 2008 1:48 pm
Now... my question is...

as a girl who is dating a gentleman who grew up in a fractured household, (divorced parents, father was abusive when he was young, grandparents divorced,) how could the ways that he responds to his family change as he grows older and continues to heal from his past experiences- and how much of that is likely to remain as it is?